A Present Government’s Prejudice Threatens A Jewel of History


Taj Mahal-Delhi-India

Print page

Is India neglecting the Taj Mahal because it was built by Muslims?

The Taj Mahal, India’s iconic monument to eternal love, has taken a beating in recent years. Its attendance figures are down, and air pollution is slowly turning its ethereal white marble yellow. Now, to make matters worse, some in India say that a staunch Hindu nationalist government recently elected in the Taj’s home state of Uttar Pradesh is starving the world-famous site of funds and support because, as it sees it, the mausoleum was built by Muslim invaders. The state’s new chief minister, the saffron-robed Hindu priest Yogi Adityanath, set the tone early on when he lamented at a rally that tiny models of the Taj Mahal are often given to visiting foreign dignitaries, saying the monument “does not reflect Indian culture.”

The Washington Post

The Taj, the country’s biggest tourism draw, was not allotted any cultural heritage funds in the state budget for the coming year. And the monument was omitted from the state’s official booklet listing all the important projects of the tourism department last week, prompting yelps of protest from the main national opposition party.Abhishek Manu Singhvi, a spokesman for the opposition Congress party, likened a tourism list without the Taj Mahal to a Hamlet-less “Hamlet.” It is a booklet on tourism and it excludes Taj Mahal, at one level it is a joke and at another level it is tragic. It is like saying we will have ‘Hamlet’ without the prince of Denmark,” Singhvi told reporters Monday. He called the omission “a clear religious bias which is completely misplaced.” Aditya Nath’s government countered by saying that the state, supported by funds from the World Bank, had slated $22 million to the monument for new gates, beautification and a multi level parking structure. “The Taj Mahal is the seventh wonder of the world. It has always been a priority not only for Uttar Pradesh but for the entire country of India,” said Awanish Awasthi, Adityanath principal secretary. “It will always be central to all our tourism policy, but there were some other new projects we wanted to feature.” The soaring mausoleum, a UNESCO World Heritage site, was built in the 17th century by the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan in memory of his late wife, Mumtaz Mahal, and is considered one of the finest examples of Indo-Islamic architecture. Famed Indian poet Rabindranath Tagore called it “one teardrop . . . on the cheek of time.”

The Real Reason The Taj Mahal Was Built

The Taj Mahal has long been a prime draw for foreign visitors, but its tourist numbers have dropped steadily since 2012, despite the opening of a highway that can bring tour buses from the nation’s capital, New Delhi, in under three hours. According to the tourism department, 480,000 foreign tourists visited the site in 2015, a 35 percent drop from the 743,000 who visited there in 2012. Domestic tourists decreased by almost 113,400 from 2012 to 2015, officials say. Tourism officials have given varying reasons for the decline, including the economy, lack of infrastructure and security concerns after a notorious 2012 gang rape in New Delhi. Golden State Warriors player Kevin Durant sparked controversy when he described the poor conditions around the Taj Mahal in blunt terms after a visit there this summer while on an official National Basketball Association tour.

“As I was driving up to the Taj Mahal, like I said, I thought that this would be holy ground, super protected, very very clean. And as I’m driving up, it’s like, s—, this used to remind me of some neighborhoods I would ride through as a kid,” he told the Athletic website. “Mud in the middle of the street, houses were not finished, but there were people living in them. No doors. No windows. The cows in the street, stray dogs and then, boom, Taj Mahal, one of the seven wonders of the world. It’s like holy s—, this was built 500 years ago and everyone comes here. It’s just an eye-opener.”

Officials in the tourism business in the city of Agra, where the Taj is located, said the monuments neglect by the administration in favor of Hindu religious sites is unfortunate, given its needs. “The current state  government is not supporting Agra as a tourist destination because of its Mughal monuments,” said Rajiv Saxena, secretary of the Tourism Guild of Agra, a trade association. “Money for tourism development has not been announced. Their focus is on religious tourism.” The Adityanath government has focused on promoting places such as the ancient city of Varanasi, a Hindu pilgrimage site, and Gorakhpur, where Adityanath is the chief priest of a large temple, critics have said. The previous state government had launched plans for a Mughal museum and an orientation center at the Taj Mahal site, but it is unclear whether those will be fully funded going forward, Saxena said. “Government programs have to be backed by the annual budget,” he said. “If there is no allocation in the budget, it will die a fast death.”